Ceramic vs. FR4 Multilayer PCBs: Which One Should You Choose?
Ceramic vs. FR4 Multilayer PCBs: Which One Should You Choose?
The printed circuit board, also known as PCBs, are used to connect different components in electronic devices. PCBs support electronic devices mechanically and physically. They are made from substrate materials and feature copper traces. FR4 and ceramic are two common materials used for making PCBs. Although both these materials have typical properties and are suitable for specific applications or performance requirements, you must consider them in depth. So, the question is, what type should you go for? In this case, you need to understand the differences between these two to maximize your PCB’s full potential. This post will explore the unique characteristics of ceramic and FR4 multilayer PCBs, giving you the knowledge needed to make a well-informed decision.
What is Ceramic Multilayer PCB?
Ceramic PCBs are engineered using ceramic materials such as alumina (Al2O3) or aluminum nitride (AlN). These materials offer exceptional thermal conductivity, high mechanical strength, and excellent electrical insulation properties. Ceramic PCBs are renowned for dissipating heat efficiently, making them ideal for applications requiring high power density and reliability.
Introduction to Popular Ceramic PCB Materials
The following ceramic materials are popularly used for making PCBs:
1. Aluminum Nitride (AlN): Aluminum Nitride has high thermal conductivity, excellent electrical insulation, and low thermal expansion, making it ideal for varying temperature applications. AlN-based PCBs are commonly used in high-power and high-frequency applications, such as RF and microwave devices, as well as in aerospace and military electronics.
2.Silicon Carbide (SiC): SiC is known for its high thermal conductivity, breakdown voltage, and excellent mechanical strength. It also has good chemical stability. SiC is mainly used in high-temperature applications and environments requiring high mechanical strength, such as power electronics and high-frequency devices.
3.Beryllium Oxide (BeO): It offers exceptional thermal conductivity, surpassing alumina and aluminum nitride. It also has excellent electrical insulation and mechanical properties. Due to its high cost and toxicity, BeO is used in specialized applications where its superior thermal performance is essential, such as in high-power semiconductor devices and advanced telecommunications equipment.
Advantages of Ceramic Multilayer PCBs
Now let’s take a look at some of the main benefits of ceramic multilayer PCBs:
1. Great thermal insulation: Ceramic is an excellent insulator. This means it stops heat from passing through, which helps protect the circuit board components from damage.
2. Suited for multilayer designs: Ceramic substrates are suited for multilayer designs. The toughness of material allows for easy addition of another layer while keeping the other components safe.
3. High thermal conductivity: Ceramic materials have high thermal conductivity, ranging from 25 to 330 W/(m·K), depending on the type used, such as alumina or beryllia. This is more than 20 times higher than that of FR-4 PCB.
4. High frequencies: Ceramic PCBs can handle high frequencies due to their dimensional and thermal stability. This makes them beneficial for industries that require high-frequency data and electrical signal transmissions, such as the medical and aerospace sectors.
What are FR4 Multilayer PCBs
FR4, short for Flame Retardant 4, is a widely used substrate material composed of woven glass fabric impregnated with epoxy resin. FR4 PCBs balance electrical performance, mechanical strength, and cost-effectiveness, making them the go-to choice for a broad range of electronic applications.
Get Introduced to Different Grades of FR4
Here are some popular grades of FR4 used for making FR4 PCBs.
1. Standard FR4: This foundational FR4 grade is cost-effective and balances electrical, mechanical, and thermal properties. This standard FR4 material has a glass transition temperature (Tg) of 130°C to 140°C, making it suited for applications with moderate thermal demands.
2. High-Frequency FR4: This FR4 grade has a low dissipation factor and dielectric constant, which makes it suitable for special FR4 high-frequency applications, including microwave and radio frequency (RF) circuits.
3. High Tg FR4: This FR4 grade is engineered for demanding environments. It has a glass transition temperature of 170°C to 180°C. This high glass transition temperature makes it a suitable choice for applications with greater power dissipation or operating temperatures. High Tg FR4 substrates are widely used in PCBs for automotive systems, power electronics, and other applications.
4. High CTI FR4: This FR4 grade is suited for applications that demand efficient heat dissipation. It has a comparative tracking index (CTI) exceeding 600 volts, contributing to its heat dissipation qualities.
5. FR4 G10: This grade shines with its properties, such as high resistance to thermal shocks, strong electrical insulation, and excellent dielectric properties.
6. FR4 without Copper Laminate: This FR4 substrate comes without copper laminate, which makes it an ideal choice for support applications, such as board supports and insulating boards.
Advantages of FR4 Multilayer PCBs
Here are the key advantages of FR4 Multilayer PCBs in detail:
1. Improved electrical performance: Multilayer PCBs improve signal integrity and reduce interference through dedicated ground and power planes, ensuring reliable high-speed signal transmission.
2. Flexible in design: FR4 Multilayer PCBs offer flexible layer configurations and are compatible with various surface finishes and assembly techniques, which makes them suitable for diverse applications.
3. Mechanical strength and durability: The combination of fiberglass and epoxy resin in FR4 provides excellent mechanical strength, making the PCBs resistant to bending and warping.
4. Diversity in applications: FR4 multilayer PCBs are used in a wide range of applications including smartphones, laptops, control systems, sensors, automation equipment, networking equipment, communication devices, etc.
Factors to Consider While Choosing Between Ceramic and FR4 Multilayer PCBs
When deciding between ceramic and FR4 multilayer PCBs, several critical factors should be considered for the best performance and reliability for your specific application. Here are the key factors to take into account:
1. Thermal management:
-
Ceramic PCBs offer superior thermal conductivity, making it a best fit for high-power and high-temperature applications. They efficiently dissipate heat and reduce the risk of overheating.
-
FR4 PCBs have excellent thermal properties; however, they are less efficient in heat dissipation than ceramics. They are suitable for applications with moderate thermal requirements.
2. Electrical performance
-
Ceramic PCBs provide excellent electrical insulation and stability with low dielectric losses and high-frequency performance.
-
FR4 PCBs offer good electrical performance for a wide range of frequencies but may not match the high-frequency capabilities of ceramics. Therefore, they are ideal for general-purpose electronic applications.
3. Complexity and Design Flexibility
-
Ceramic PCBs are used in applications that require fewer layers due to higher material and processing costs.
-
FR4 PCBs offer greater design flexibility with the ability to create complex, multilayered boards.
4. Environmental Considerations
-
Ceramic PCBs are more environmentally friendly due to the natural and recyclable nature of ceramic materials. They can withstand higher temperatures without degrading.
-
While FR4 PCBs are recyclable, the epoxy resin and fiberglass composition can pose environmental challenges if not properly managed.
5. Mechanical Strength and Durability
-
Ceramic PCBs is highly durable and resistant to mechanical stress, vibration, and environmental factors. That’s why it is suitable for harsh environments such as aerospace, military, and industrial applications.
-
FR4 PCBs provide good mechanical strength and durability, but may not be as robust as ceramic PCBs in extreme conditions. So it is best fit for the consumer electronics and standard industrial applications and cost-sensitive applications.
6. Cost
-
Ceramic PCBs are generally more expensive due to the cost of materials and manufacturing processes. That’s the reason why it is suitable where performance requirements justify the higher cost.
-
FR4 PCBs are more cost-effective which makes them suitable for large-scale production
7. Manufacturing and Lead Time
-
Manufacturing processes for ceramic PCBs can be more complex and time-consuming.
-
Manufacturing processes for FR4 PCBs are well-established and scalability leads to shorter lead times and faster production cycles.
Choosing between ceramic and FR4 multilayer PCBs depends on balancing performance requirements, cost, and specific application needs. Ceramic PCBs excel in high-performance, high-reliability applications with demanding thermal and electrical requirements. FR4 multilayer PCBs are suitable for various applications, particularly where complex designs and multiple layers are needed. Apart from this post, if you still need assistance in choosing between these two types of PCBs or you are looking for PCB assembly services, you can trust Twisted Traces. The experts at the company will work closely with you to choose the right substrate for your application.
.png)
